Eisenstadt, in his 1973 book traditional patrimonialism and modern neopatrimonialism, deriving it from max webers term, patrimonialism, who used the term to describe a system of rule based on administrative and military personnel, who were responsible only to the ruler. Beyond a catchall concept abstract the article provides a critical discussion of the literature on patrimonialism and neopatrimonialism as far as the use in development studies in general or african studies in particular is concerned. But aspects of both the arbitrary use of power by rulers and the employment of mercenaries and retainers can be. Neopatrimonialism, good governance, corruption and accounting in africa. Instead of the prevailing view that postcolonial states are condemned to their colonial design, and that authoritarian rule favors economic development, my study shows that nonwestern state formation is nonlinear and follows a cyclical pattern between predation and developmentalism, the excesses of which could be moderated. Pdf what neopatrimonialism is six questions to the. The main focus of this essay, because i believe the comparative literature to be largely imprecise and. To what extent is neopatrimonialism the unchanging way in. To overcome the catchall use of the concept the authors.
All giga working papers are available as pdf files free of charge at. Instead, by finally explaining the major differences between traditional and modern patrimonial i. Democratization in southeast asia abstract the theory of democratization by elections lindberg 2009 holds that electionseven when flawedcan have an independent causal effect on democratic transitions. Current usages of the terms patrimonial and neopatrimonial in the context of africa are conceptually problematical and amount to a serious misreading of weber. In contemporary neopatrimonialism, relationships of loyalty and. Patriarchy and patrimonialism in early modern europe publication date.
He has published articles in sociology, political science, economics, and history journals on topics including the causes and consequences of warfare, state formation, the origins of democratic institutions, and the methodology of comparativehistorical sociology. Key words neopatrimonialism, clientelism, patronage, good governance. Information and translations of neopatrimonialism in the most comprehensive dictionary definitions resource on the web. Corruption and resource distribution in neopatrimonial systems. But aspects of both the arbitrary use of power by rulers and the employment of mercenaries and retainers can be found in contemporary. Traditional patrimonialism and modern neopatrimonialism studies in comparative modernization series. Webers patrimonial domination and its interpretations hinnerk bruhns 3. Traditional patrimonialism and modern neopatrimonialism studies in comparative modernization series eisenstadt, s. Because it is social accepted, neopatrimonial politics have managed to permeate all political levels, affecting the distribution of resources and distorting development plans and diverting aid funds to ensure the survival of the system.
His use of the term patrimonial delineated a legitimate type of authority, not a type of regime, and included notions of reciprocity and voluntary compliance between rulers and the ruled. Nothing, therefore, reminiscent of an integrated, systematic and coherent order based around the three principles of legitimacy legal, traditional and charismatic with which we have. Second, the traditional basis of patrimonial authority may be less pronounced. Oct 15, 2012 the article goes on to further delineate patrimonialism from neopatrimonialism by stating something very similar to the definitions at the beginning of this document. Traditional patrimonialism and modern neopatrimonialism by eisenstadt, s. Jan 24, 2010 neopatrimonialism or modern patrimonialism, erdmann and engel. Pdf neopatrimonialism, good governance, corruption and. Colonialism, neopatrimonialism, and hybrid state formation in. Neopatrimonialism and public sector performance and reform. Traditional patrimonialism and modern neopatrimonialism in.
The conditions of protest behavior in american cities. Traditional patrimonialism and modern neopatrimonialism sage research papers in social sciences, ser. Neopatrimonial politics in the anc african affairs. Neopatrimonialism revisited beyond a catchall concept gero.
Idealism versus pragmatism article pdf available in journal of accounting in emerging economies 72 may 2017 with. Traditional patrimonialism and modern neopatrimonialism, sage publications to explain the. Neopatrimonialism, which is a modern form of the traditional patrimonial form of rule, is a mixed system. Clientelism and patrimonialism in international relations. Patrimonialism connotes that a patron in a certain social and.
Patrimonialism is a social system in which a royal elite rules through personal and arbitrary control over a bureaucracy and over slaves, mercenaries, and conscripts who have no power themselves and serve only to enforce the monarchs rule. Whereas patrimonialism refers to a traditional form of government described by influential german sociologist max weber, the term neopatrimonialism is intended to signify that, following the imposition of the colonial state, african political systems can no longer be treated. Neopatrimonialism in africa and beyond 1st edition. A patrimonial system is based on informal or personal relationships.
Patrimonialism is a form of governance in which all power flows directly from the leader. Patrimonial authority and administration are no longer found in the pure form described by weber. The case of ghana and nigerian airlines abstract this paper draws on the concept of neopatrimonialism eisenstadt, 1973. Series studies in comparative modernization series sage research papers in the social sciences. Neopatrimonialism revisited beyond a catchall concept pdf. Patrimonial systems have been far less stable and more prone to. Eisenstadt shmuel n traditional patrimonialism and modern. Colonialism, neopatrimonialism, and hybrid state formation. In his 1973 book, traditional patrimonialism and modern neopatrimonialism, shmuel n. Despite the recent growth of this literature, questions. How does neopatrimonialism affect the african states revenues.
Edgar kiser is a professor of sociology at the university of washington. Studies in comparative modernization series volume 90, issue 3 of studies in comparative modernization series. The tale of two national african airlines abstract this paper draws on the concept of neopatrimonialism eisenstadt, 1973. Neopatrimonialism neopatrimonialism is a modern form of the traditional patrimonial system of rule, as a mixed system that includes elements of both patrimonialism and legalrational rule. During the last decade, the concept of patrimonialism has become firmly embedded in political science and the sociological literature, being used primarily to explain the operation of bureaucracies in. A theoretical framework for understanding the practice of politics in africa from the colonial era onwards. Webers patrimonialism is, rather, a specific form of.
Neopatrimonialism is the foundation stone for the system which drives african politics. Rethinking patrimonialism and neopatrimonialism in africa. Traditional patrimonialism and modern neopatrimonialism. It has been found most often in asia and china in particular. The very essence of patrimonialism consists in the idea that the whole government authority and the economic rights which correspond to it, tend to be treated as privately appropriated. During the last decade, the concept of patrimonialism has become firmly embedded in political science and the sociological literature, being used primarily to explain the operation of bureaucracies in the underdeveloped world. Neopatrimonialism is a system of social hierarchy where patrons use state resources in order to. Neopatrimonialism in africa and beyond 1st edition daniel. Idealism versus pragmatism article pdf available in journal of accounting in emerging economies 72. Oct 12, 2012 daniel bachs chapter patrimonialism and neopatrimonialism.
Origin and definition of the term neopatrimonialism as a distinct term is generally held to have originated with shmuel n. Neopatrimonialism and democracy neopatrimonialism is a form of rule commonly associated with ineffective governance in africa. The very essence of patrimonialism consists in the idea that the whole government authority and the economic rights which correspond to it, tend to be treated as privately appropriated economic advantages medard. This has given birth to hybrid states, where modern formal. Patrimonialism definition in the study of sociology. He goes on to add that neopatrimonialism, unlike traditional patrimonialism, exists with bureaucratic systems and at least a pretense of legalrational state governmental legitimacy.
In contemporary political science literature, neopatrimonialism refers to the simultaneous operation of two weberian ideal typical forms of domination. There is no distinction between the public and private domains. Patriarchy and patrimonialism in early modern europe. The term neopatrimonialism was first used by eisenstadt 1973 to distinguish patrimonialism in traditional and modern contexts. Neopatrimonialism, patronage and factionalism in postsoviet uzbekistan alisher ikhamov 15.
The article goes on to further delineate patrimonialism from neopatrimonialism by stating something very similar to the definitions at the beginning of this document. There, patrimonialism and neopatrimonialism have been associated with a greater axiological neutrality than in africa due, inter alia, to the preservation of an analytical dichotomy between regulated and predatory forms of neopatrimonialism. Personal rulership, patrimonialism and empire building in the new states. Traditional patrimonialism and modern neopatrimonialism, sage publications to explain the failure of the national airlines of ghana and nigeria. Berlusconismo as a case of hybrid neopatrimonialism mauro barisione 16. Pdf what neopatrimonialism is six questions to the concept.
Eisenstadt used the derived term neopatrimonialism to describe a mixed system in which formal institutions of modernity from the west are imitated, with most informal institutions remaining of a patrimonial nature. Neglected for all too long, the study of regulated forms of neopatrimonialism in africa calls for fresh. Neopatrimonialism revisited beyond a catchall concept. Jul 28, 2017 he therefore used the term neopatrimonialism to denote the operation of patrimonialism in modern societies eisenstadt 1973. Notes on patrimonialism in africa theobald, bach, pitcher. Assessing decentralized and privatized tax administration. In their analysis of neopatrimonial politics, modern democratic procedures as well as rational legality are built on a foundation of traditional and highly personalised reciprocities and loyalties.
Resource distribution in neopatrimonial systems forms of resource distribution neopatrimonialism refers to a system of governance where the formal rationallegal state apparatus coexists and is supplanted by an informal patrimonial system of governance. The model of the political entrepreneur daniel compagnon 5. It tries to establish in which areas consensus can be found in the application of the concept of neopatrimonialism. Definition of neopatrimonialism in the definitions. Specifically, the ideal t y pe of patrimonialism connotes that a patron. Is patrimonialism really the source of africas poor governance. It tries to establish in which areas consen sus can be found in the application of the concept of neopatrimonialism. A crucial difference between the concept of patrimonialism and the contemporary concepts of totalitarianism and authoritarianism is that the patrimonial form tends to be associated with traditional, premodern, precapitalist societies. Traditional patrimonialism and modern neopatrimonialism by. Mikhail ilyin weberian notion of patrimonialism proved to be very productive and produced in contemporary scholarly literature a host of derivative terms and interpretations.
1472 1509 419 112 6 641 309 493 1203 1001 193 552 527 1531 1417 754 1463 1429 1381 659 813 954 393 655 428 51 361 1418 972 590 142 1485 1222 758 66 681 203