Did gerard butler really sing in phantom of the opera. Minnie driver mimes all her singing parts in the new phantom of the opera movie, it has been revealed. Minnie drive played carlotta in the 2004 film version of the musical phantom of the opera, however because of her lack of experience in opera, opera singer margaret preece overdubbed her singing voice. With hundreds of actors, including understudies, playing the lead role of the phantom in andrew lloyd webbers the phantom of the opera in its many productions throughout the world, it is a hard task to choose the top ten talented men who have stepped behind the mask to portray the enigmatic musical genius. Watch the minnie driver the phantom of the opera interview. She is better known as a hollywood actress than as a singer, but minnie driver showed off her considerable musical talents when she performed at annabels. While rossum certainly could sing, her voice still sounded too small and underwhelming for christine. Her career wasnt exactly on the upswing either, so casting her for star power makes little sense.
The only reason i can think of to explain her casting is that someone though, we need a stuck up, obnoxious, no talent, diva, i know. Most of the actors have a background in musicals or opera, but driver a skilled singer had no experience in opera and was dubbed by margaret preece, a singing teacher from solihull, uk. When you think of minnie driver, you most likely think of her oscarnominated performance in good will hunting, opposite matt damon and ben affleck. According to her bio, minnie driver was a singer long before she ever became an actress. Minnie driver sings, stripped down and haunting minnie driver is probably best known for her acting roles, but the huskyvoiced actor is also an accomplished singer. His voice calls to her, nurturing her extraordinary talents from the shadows of the opera. In fact, the british actress, best known for her academy awardnominated performance in 1997s good will hunting, proved her vocal prowess even before landing her first oncamera role. Minnie driver comes out singing in phantom of the opera. If they had someone do the singing for him they certainly wouldve chosen someone with a more traditional, phantom voice. We undertook this difficult task, however, and here is our list of top ten phantom. Minnie driver is equally at home telling an offcolor joke or spelling aeschylus correctly on a crossword puzzle, as she did recently in a rare moment of repose at a midtown manhattan hotel. Best phantoms in phantom of the opera top ten list.
As phantom of the opera hits its 30th anniversary, the longrunning show can offer lots of lessons for other broadway shows. Earlier this year minnie driver showed off her singing talent in her debut album. The michael crawfordsarah brightman cast soundtrack was on constant rotation in my house, and i had big broadway dreams of appearing in the horror musical classic. We are changing the login scheme for contributors for simpler login and to better support using multiple devices.
Like any musical theater lover of a certain age, i grew up on phantom of the opera. Get the details on the phantom of the opera star emmy rossums career, her love life and her take on all the sex scenes on her tv show shameless, at. There actually are simple steps to dramatically reduce online tracking. I dont feel her version at all it seems so just not opera type style. Even though minnie driver didnt do her singing voice, she was the. Accordingly, everything ive got in my pocket, her first album, contains ten driver originals and a cover of bruce springsteens hungry heart. Personally, i think they did, because at the point of filming that, she was really a nobody and they wouldnt hire a nobody for that big a singing dependent role if she couldnt in fact sing. I know that gerard butler plays the phant question and answer in the alws phantom of the opera movie club. Really good singing with feeling, and without affectation. Although it could have been a lot worse the phantom of the opera fan. I know minnie driver played the part of carlotta in the 2004 film version of phantom of the opera, but i am curious if she actually sang the part or had someone voice over her singing.
Filmgoers interested in hearing what she really sounds like should not. Looking elegant in a new york hotel room, minnie driver, who gives a scenestealing performance in phantom of the opera, is usually coy about her personal life, but happily admits to going out. Does minnie driver sing the songs in phantom of the opera. He can sing those powerful notes and the gentle floating. Due to drivers lack of experience in opera, her singing voice was dubbed by opera. Stream everything ive got in my pocket by minnie driver and tens of millions of other songs on all your. Chatting with actress and singer minnie driver the. Minnie driver, though saddled with odd directorial choices, gives the only. Why did they decide not to dub pierce brosnans singing in. Minnie driver on the other hand had someone else sing for her in the movie. Phantom of the opera new and unimproved, by kurt loder mtv.
Your browser does not currently recognize any of the video formats available. Emmy rossum mystic river is sweetly appealing, and, having trained at new yorks metropolitan opera, can really sing. Ok so i know some of you disagree, but is indeed minnie driver singing this song. Shes a singer in the film, but its such a weird moment. However, driver did contribute the films end title song, learn to be lonely, written. I have to get my record out before the movies out because. The project began as an exhortation by producer marc doc dauer, who had heard drivers songs accompanied by her selfadmitted mangled guitar playing. And never is that made more apparent than in joel schumachers 2004 adaptation. Miming minnie is a phantom singer daily mail online. However, minnie driver did sing the end song during the credits titled learn to be lonely. I could sing chicago or guys and dolls, but this is opera, she adds.
Exclusive minnie driverphantom of the opera interview by paul fischer in new york. The phantom of the opera is a musical with the musical score composed by andrew lloyd webber. Looking elegant in a hew york hotel room, minnie driver, who gives a scenestealing performance in phantom of the opera, is usually coy about her personal life, but happily admits to going out with an australian. Schumacher 2004 film version, she was played by minnie driver.
Amelia fiona minnie driver born 31 january 1970 is an englishamerican actress and singersongwriter. When matt damon broke up with minnie driver on oprah. It takes a long time for anyone to start singing in the film, and then theres. And then i grew up and realized this show is a mess. All of the principal actors sang in the film except for minnie driver. I really do enjoy a lot of it i fastforward through that entire sequence. Minnie driver for the phantom of the opera dark horizons. For an actress, minnie driver packs a powerful soprano in the new movie. I really have no words for how great ramin is as phantom. Minnie driver comes out singing in phantom of the opera mtv. Since the crew didnt want to have to actually build an opera house, the exterior is.
Everything ive got in my pocket minnie driver songs. Because its a movie version of the phantom of the opera. Like its eponymous hero, this adaptation of andrew lloyd webbers stage musical the phantom of the opera is shockingly inyourface. No, its the ghost who lives in this opera house and really has it out for minnie for some reason. Every time companies squeeze to get lower production costs, faster production, its nobody but the working women who suffer and their families back at home. Minnie by way of an actual opera singer begins rehearsing, until a backdrop falls on her. Minnie driver only sings the closing learn to be lonely of andrew lloyd webbers phantom of the opera. And was she tempted by the fact that she got to sing.
Who knew that a version of phantom of the opera, starring gerard butler of all. Wow magic sing song download year old opera singer diction for singer. Learn to be lonely lyrics phantom of the opera youtube. Now i cant really blame minnie for not having the same range as needed for the movie, but that being said, there was nothing about her voice that really stood out. Breaking up is hard to do maybe thats why matt damon decided to cut ties with minnie driver by announcing their separation on national tv, instead of telling her directly and in private. Broadway can learn a few things from phantom of the opera. Carlotta giudicelli is a fictional character from gaston lerouxs 1909 novel the phantom of the.
Does minnie driver sing in phantom of the opera tags. Her voice is dubbed by a real opera singer who is singing terrible on. Driver has been nominated for the academy award for best supporting actress and a screen actors guild award for her role as skylar in gus van sants good will hunting 1997. Minnie did lend her actual voice to the song learn to be lonely during the end credits. Shes hilarious, and brings a real sense of comic timing with her i never really considered driver to be a solid comedic actress before, yet she proves me wrong. When she does, however, croaking noises come out of her mouth and the.
Did minnie driver sing in phantom of the opera answers. Driver, minnie, minnie driver everything ive got in my pocket music. What went wrong with the phantom of the opera film. In the novel, the phantom of the opera, was christine a ballet dancer before. Audreys hepburns was dubbed in my fair lady and minnie driver phantom of. Did minnie driver do her own singing in phantom of the opera. I saw the movie a day ago, and needless to say, i loved it. Minnie driver shows off another talent as she sings for. Minnie driver singing in the governess cristina dascalescu. Minnie driver the phantom of the opera interview 2004. In this webexclusive clip, actress minnie driver about a boy who is also a songwriter performs beloved, from her album seastories, with her musical collaborator marc doc dauer. Why did they decide not to dub pierce brosnans singing in mamma mia. Did minnie driver sing carlotta in phantom or was it voice. Margaret preece who is a singing teacher from solihull, uk.
While the british actress most recently seen on san francisco. The phantom of the opera 2004 minnie driver as carlotta. Due to drivers lack of experience in opera, her singing voice was dubbed by opera singer margaret preece, although she lent her actual voice to the song learn to be lonely during the end credits. Or maybe you contemplate her memorable turns in the circle of friends and grosse point blank or even her hilarious cameo in goldeneye, where she plays a lounge singer who cant sing. As a birthday gift i bought him tickets to her concert and i gotta say she can sing. Minnie driver has waited more than a decade to reveal her. Driver, minnie, minnie driver everything ive got in my.
In the lloyd webberjoel schumacher 2004 film version, she was played by minnie driver. I have to get my record out before the movies out because people are. Minnie driver on whats in store for about a boy cbs news. And then theres the odd choice of having minnie driver sing billy idols white wedding.
273 937 870 345 1656 654 489 231 313 401 609 436 1029 1493 486 1021 1466 1407 1165 1499 771 1065 1407 1071 1405 1037 301 367 1311 1011 1466 1410 230